I haven't been able to reply to comments from within the module -- if I really want to say something, I have to just click 'comment' when I am outside the edit mode.  That's not as good obviously.  Is that a bug, or do I simply not know what I'm doing?

Flynn_the_Cat wrote:

I have an issue, not exactly sure it's a bug, I'd like clarified - if you reply to someone's comment - specifically -  but they are not subscribed to the whole guestbook, shouldn't they still get a message? (I don't want to follow guestbooks on most lenses, but I would like to know if someone replies to me - which is what te follow option was for, originally, methinks!)

I agree completely. I was excited to see that we could subscribe to a Guestbook but most of the time I just want to receive an answer to my message. It also seems that it would help a lot with costumers who would like to ask about a product or just a way to get a good conversation going.

I'm getting a problem that my options for the Guestbook do not save.

E.g. I don't want to receive emails that let me know there is a comment on my guestbook and yet clicking on the Do not send me emails option doesn't always work.

I usually like to approve comments but rather than receive emails (which I do not want) I've had to set it up to allow comments to go directly through without approval.

Just totally failed to leave a comment. Tried to refresh several times. Still no joy. Definitely worse than before!
Can't believe that a guest reader would try this hard!

I've had some heads-up that people weren't able to leave a guest book comment in some guest books.

I'm still having random problems with posting comments. Sometimes they process normally, other times I get the fail notice and must refresh to gain success. Hope this is fixed soon. I hate to lose train of thought leaving a comment ... I'm starting to copy them before submitting, just in case.

jptanabe wrote:

Funny thing I found out was that I can post comments in Guestbooks when I'm using Firefox, but not Chrome!
Sorry to all the lenses I failed to post comments in while browsing happily in Chrome.

Just had the same experience. Tried repeatedly using chrome and wasn't getting anywhere. IE users are also mentioning the problem.

Installed Firefox and it worked first time. This does suggest a compatibility problem with some of the other major browsers, we need a fix.